AI Chatbots and Medical Advice: What Students Should Understand (Career Counseling Perspective)

-

 


Nowadays, whenever we feel confused about something—whether it’s studies, career, or even health—we often turn to AI chatbots. They give quick answers, are available anytime, and feel easy to talk to. Because of this, many students have started depending on them for important information, including health-related advice.

But a recent report by NDTV has shown something concerning. It found that AI chatbots sometimes give incorrect or unsafe advice about serious illnesses like cancer. From a career counseling point of view, this is something students really need to understand, because it affects how they think, decide, and grow.

Source Link : ( https://www.ndtv.com/feature/study-finds-ai-chatbots-often-recommend-problematic-cancer-treatments-11388574?utm_source=traffic&utm_medium=Jason&utm_campaign=OEM2 )

What the Study Shows

Researchers asked different AI chatbots questions about cancer treatment. The results showed that almost half of the answers were problematic.

This means:

Some answers were incomplete

Some were confusing

Some even suggested treatments that are not scientifically proven

In a few cases, the chatbots didn’t strongly recommend proper treatments like chemotherapy and instead mentioned alternative options. Now imagine someone who is already worried about their health reading such advice—it can easily mislead them.

Why This Matters for Students

You might think, “This is about health, not career.” But actually, it is deeply connected to career development.

1. It Affects How You Make Decisions

If you start trusting AI blindly, you may stop thinking critically. But in any career—whether you want to be a psychologist, doctor, teacher, or anything else—decision-making and critical thinking are very important.

2. It Can Influence Your Knowledge

Students who are studying subjects like psychology or science might start learning incorrect information if they depend only on AI. This can affect both exams and future understanding.

3. It Impacts Your Well-being

Wrong medical advice can create fear, stress, or even harm your health. And if your health is not good, it automatically affects your studies and career progress.

Why AI Makes These Mistakes

Ø  It’s important to understand that AI is not a human expert.

Ø  It does not “think” like a doctor

Ø  It does not understand your personal situation

Ø  It only gives answers based on the data it has learned

Sometimes that data includes wrong or outdated information. Also, AI often sounds very confident, even when it is wrong, which makes people trust it easily.

Important Lesson for Career Growth

As a student, this situation teaches you something very important:

ü  Don’t depend completely on AI

ü  AI is a tool, not a decision-maker. You can use it for help, but you should not trust it blindly—especially in serious matters like health.

ü  Always verify important information

For anything important:

ü  Talk to a real expert (doctor, teacher, counselor)

ü  Check reliable sources

ü  Think logically before accepting any answer

ü  Develop critical thinking

This is one of the most important skills for your future.

A successful person is not someone who knows everything, but someone who knows how to think and decide correctly.

Role of Career Counseling

In career counseling, we don’t just guide students about jobs—we help them become aware and responsible individuals.

This issue shows why counseling is important:

Ø  To teach students how to use technology wisely

Ø  To help them understand the difference between real and misleading information

Ø  To build confidence in their own thinking and decisions

As a counselor, the aim is to make students independent thinkers, not dependent on AI or any shortcut.

But the question arises here, “Is AI Completely Bad?” And the answer is, “No, not at all”. AI can still be helpful:

*     It can explain topics in simple language

*     It can help in studying and research

*     It can save time

But the key point is:

Use AI as support, not as final authority.

FINAL THOUGHT

This whole issue gives us a very simple but powerful message:

Your life decisions—whether related to health, studies, or career—should never depend only on AI.

AI can guide you, but it cannot replace human knowledge, experience, and understanding.

So as a student, always remember:

Think before you trust

Verify before you act

And when it comes to serious matters, always rely on real professionals

Because your future depends not just on information, but on how wisely you use it.

https://www.rajnibhasin.in
099107 65844

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

-
Image
Choosing the right stream after Class 10 is one of the most crucial decisions in a student’s academicjourney. This decision lays the foundation for future career paths, higher education, and long-term professional satisfaction. However, many students make this choice based on marks, peer pressure, or parental expectations—often leading to confusion, dissatisfaction, or even career setbacks later in life. This is where  career counseling plays a transformative role . Why Stream Selection After 10th is So Important After Class 10, students typically choose between  Science, Commerce, and Arts/Humanities . Each stream opens different career opportunities, and selecting the wrong one can limit future options or lead to a lack of interest and motivation. A well-informed decision at this stage ensures: Clarity in career direction Better academic performance Long-term satisfaction and success The Role of Career Counseling Career counseling helps students make  informed, personal...
Read more

AI Can Comfort You, But It Cannot Hold Your Relationship

-
Image
  These days, when something feels off in a relationship, many people don’t pick up the phone or sit down with their partner—they open a chat window. They type what they’re feeling, explain their situation, and within seconds, they get a response that sounds calm, understanding, and supportive. And honestly, it feels good. It feels like someone is finally listening without interrupting or judging. The India Today article points out that more and more people are turning to AI tools for emotional clarity, especially when they feel confused or hurt in their relationships. It’s not that relationships are suddenly breaking because of technology—but something subtle is definitely changing in how people process emotions and seek support. From a relationship counseling perspective, this shift is important to understand. Why AI Feels So Comforting!!! Let’s be real—relationships are not always easy spaces to express yourself. You might hesitate because: “What if my partner doesn’t un...
Read more

Education Policies: Easing Pressures or Building Pressures

-
Image
  The discussion around the 3-language formula in Class 9 and its sudden disappearance in Class 10 has created confusion for students, parents, teachers, and even schools. Many students spend an entire year studying an extra language, giving their time, energy, and focus to it, only to later discover that the same language may not even remain compulsory in Class 10. Naturally, students begin asking an important question — are we actually learning something meaningful, or are we simply increasing academic pressure without a clear purpose? The idea behind the 3-language formula was never wrong. In fact, it was introduced with a positive vision. India is a diverse country with many languages and cultures, and the policy aimed to help students connect with their regional language, Hindi, and English together. The intention was to improve communication, cultural understanding, and national unity. On paper, the idea sounds progressive and valuable. But when policies are implemented w...
Read more